Finance
10
min read
Do loyalty cards in hospitality really pay off?
What research says about stamp and loyalty cards in a café, supermarkets and shops, and how to use POS data to work out whether your card pays off.

Ten coffees, the eleventh free: a loyalty card is quick to make. Whether it pays off is less straightforward. Every reward costs money, even if the guest would have come anyway, and that has to be made up for by visits that would not have happened without the card. This article sets out the research and shows how to work out whether your card pays off. It matters now because guests are looking harder at the bill, as we described in the Top 10 hospitality trends for 2027. The data is as of 17 November 2026. One limitation up front: we found no research on cards in restaurants in which guest behavior was measured, with POS data or a control group. There are survey studies, such as one on desired rewards among visitors to an arts festival in Pennsylvania and restaurant guests in Las Vegas (Jang and Mattila, 2005); we do not use those as evidence.
1. A stamp card shifts when guests come
In a café on an American university campus, Kivetz, Urminsky and Zheng followed guests with a card on which ten coffees entitled them to a free coffee (Journal of Marketing Research, February 2006). From 949 completed cards it emerged that guests came back faster as the reward came closer: the time between the ninth and the tenth coffee was on average 0.7 days shorter than between the first and the second, an acceleration of 20%. For guests who started a second card, the pace after redeeming fell back to what it was at the start. The authors estimate that guests who completed their card bought about 11 coffees per month, against 9 at the pace of the first stamp.
According to the abstract of Nunes and Drèze, a task of eight steps is completed more often and faster if you turn it into ten steps, two of which have already been taken (Journal of Consumer Research, March 2006). Kivetz and colleagues tested it in the same café: 108 guests were randomly given a card of ten boxes or a card of twelve boxes with two already stamped. Both required ten purchases; the pre-stamped card was full after 12.7 days on average, against 15.6 days.
What it means for your venue. The study by Kivetz and colleagues concerns one café with several locations on a campus, and mainly guests who completed their card; what it delivers for you on balance, you have to check for yourself. In a second part of that study, a website where participants rated music for reward certificates, the chance that a visit ended was greatest right after a reward had been earned. What you can do now. You can consider giving a card two stamps when it is issued and making it two boxes longer: the number of purchases needed stays the same.
2. Extra visits or the same guests?
It is harder to know whether a card brings guests in for extra visits. Leenheer, Van Heerde, Bijmolt and Smidts followed 1,909 Dutch households across seven supermarket programs, from July 1998 to July 2000 (International Journal of Research in Marketing, March 2007; we read the working version). In the raw figures, members spent on average 36% of their supermarket expenditure at the chain, non-members 7%. After correcting for the fact that loyal customers sign up more often, a difference of 4.1 percentage points remained, about seven times smaller. For all seven programs, the extra revenue exceeded the cost of the rewards, although that concerns revenue and not profit.
At a franchise chain of convenience stores, Liu saw that customers who bought a lot at the start redeemed rewards most often without changing their behavior, while customers with low or moderate use gradually bought more (Journal of Marketing, October 2007; sample not stated). At supermarkets, Meyer-Waarden and Benavent found that heavy customers sign up earlier, that behavior changes only little after signing up, and that small changes in loyalty seem to fade out six to nine months after signing up (Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, September 2009; sample not stated).
There is also a more positive picture. In a chain of men's hair salons, Gopalakrishnan and colleagues followed more than 5,500 customers for thirty months (Marketing Science, online March 2021). Some were signed up automatically at the start, so they did not choose the moment of signing up themselves; as a caveat, the authors note that these customers may differ from non-members in other respects. According to their model, customer value rose by almost 30% over five years, mainly because fewer customers stayed away; spending per visit hardly changed. That customer value is expected revenue (visits times $21), not profit. A meta-analysis of 434 effects from 78 samples finds that membership is positively associated with outcomes before, during and after the purchase (Chen, Evanschitzky and Blut, Journal of Retailing, July 2026; the abstract does not say whether self-selection was corrected for).
3. The risk: a discount for those who came anyway
Every reward is a discount. If it goes to a guest who would have come anyway, you forgo the selling price of what you give away and no visit is added. In Harvard Business Review (2006), Nunes and Drèze recommend not making the eleventh purchase free: anyone who buys a product ten times will probably buy the eleventh too. Better to choose a reward that lets guests try something new. That is advice, not a measurement. On stopping, Leenheer and colleagues say only, in a footnote of the working version, that abolishing a program can provoke strongly negative reactions; they did not investigate that.
4. Why guests come back
On Dutch guests we found one source: KHN (Royal Horeca Netherlands, the hospitality employers' association) reported on 10 June 2026, about a NielsenIQ study (sample not stated), that food quality is one of the most important factors in choosing a venue, not specifically in coming back.
Toast, a provider of POS and restaurant software, reports in its Regulars Report of April 2026 (a survey of 1,500 American adults who eat out or order at least twice a month) that 48% feel most valued when staff remember their name or usual order, against 22% with a points program (Toast, 2 July 2026). Read that as a signal.
Tanford combined 102 studies with 423 effects from the hospitality industry (Cornell Hospitality Quarterly, May 2016): satisfaction, emotional commitment, service quality, trust and switching costs are strongly related to loyalty, but the effects get smaller as you move from attitude via intention to behavior. So what guests say is not necessarily what they do.
What you can do now. Ask your regular guests why they come back, before you choose a discount as the answer.
5. Work out for yourself whether your card pays off
Choose a fixed measurement period, for example twelve weeks, and compare it with a period without the card, such as the same weeks a year earlier, adjusted for the general trend. Also look at the weeks after it ends: a card can bring visits forward instead of adding them. Then work this out:
Net result = (extra bills × margin per bill) minus (redeemed rewards × cost per reward) minus fixed costs
Extra bills: the number of bills in the card period minus the number you expected without the card. This is an estimate.
Margin per bill: average spending minus variable costs such as purchasing. Use the margin, not the revenue.
Cost per reward: calculated conservatively as the selling price of what you give away, because you do not know whether the guest would have come without the card.
Fixed costs: cards, software or hours.
With a paper card you count the cards handed in; the rest you get from your POS. The break-even point is the number of extra bills at which the net result is zero: (redeemed rewards × cost per reward + fixed costs) divided by margin per bill.
Example calculation (hypothetical numbers, not a result for your venue or for hospitality). A coffee bar gives the eleventh coffee free. A coffee costs €3.00; an average bill is €5.00 and yields €3.50 in margin. In twelve weeks there are 400 more bills than in the comparison period, 300 rewards are redeemed and the fixed costs are €200. Extra margin: 400 × €3.50 = €1,400. Rewards: 300 × €3.00 = €900. Net: €1,400 minus €900 minus €200 = €300. Break-even: (€900 + €200) divided by €3.50 is about 314 extra bills, so 1.05 per reward; here there are 400, so 1.33 per reward.
If you use Guestit, the analysis of your data is under Insights (analytics). You calculate the margin yourself using your purchase prices.
6. What you can do without a card
For these alternatives we found no research on the effect on visits that compares them with a card; they are ways of working, not measured effects.
Recognize returning guests. Address regular guests by name and remember their usual order.
Use reservation data. What a guest tells you when making a reservation, such as an allergy or a birthday, your team can know in advance. The rules below apply to advertising.
Give a reason to come back soon that is not a discount, such as a new dish. This is an idea from Foodie Coaches; we found no research on it.
7. Guest data and the GDPR
As soon as data on a card can be traced to a person, you are processing personal data. According to the Autoriteit Persoonsgegevens (AP, the Dutch data protection authority), that is all information about an identified or identifiable person, such as name, address, phone number, customer numbers, what someone does or buys on the internet, and whether someone has an allergy. In our reading (the AP does not mention this), a paper card with only stamps records nothing about a person; as soon as you link a name, email address, card number or buying behavior to it, it does. Three points:
Legal basis. You need a legal basis and you determine it yourself, before you start; the AP gives no advice on this.
No more than necessary, only for that purpose. According to KVK (the Dutch Chamber of Commerce), you need an email address for a newsletter but not a date of birth, and you do not use an email address you requested for the invoice for advertising. According to the AP, strict rules apply to advertising, and anyone who relies on consent must be able to demonstrate it.
Retention period. The GDPR does not name a fixed period. You keep data no longer than necessary, set the period per purpose, can justify it and state it in your privacy statement (AP).
For your venue
Research gives no clear-cut yes or no. Cards can influence the pace of visits and guests staying away, but part of the measured effect comes from guests who were loyal anyway. If you want to try a card or already have one, work out whether it pays off over a fixed period. If you want to stop, announce a date and honor current cards: that advice comes from Foodie Coaches and we found no research on it.
How we compiled this
For Kivetz and colleagues, Gopalakrishnan and colleagues, and Leenheer and colleagues (working version; we could not open the published version, so numbers may differ) we read the text itself. Of the other studies we read only the abstract, because SAGE and ScienceDirect, among others, were not accessible; of Harvard Business Review only a summary, and of the KHN study the public part. In Crossref and OpenAlex, none of the studies is listed with a correction or retraction. The formula and the example calculation are ours.
This article was inspired by Are Restaurant Loyalty Cards Worth It? (2026) by Foodie Coaches. We did not adopt their figures because they are Australian and name no source. Their idea that a card is mainly a discount for guests who came back anyway, and that recognition and personal contact build loyalty, we tested against research, with a mixed result. Their advice to give a reason to come back soon and, when stopping, to honor current cards, we adopted as a way of working; we found no research on that. Their idea that a card only makes sense at a launch or to fill quiet periods, with an end date, we could not substantiate; for quiet periods we found only a scenario experiment (Heo, International Journal of Hospitality Management, 2026; abstract), without measured behavior. Do you have a correction or a better source? Email hey@guestit.nl.
Sources
Jang and Mattila, An examination of restaurant loyalty programs: what kinds of rewards do customers prefer?, International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management (August 2005; abstract)
Kivetz, Urminsky and Zheng, The Goal-Gradient Hypothesis Resurrected: Purchase Acceleration, Illusionary Goal Progress, and Customer Retention, Journal of Marketing Research (February 2006)
Nunes and Drèze, The Endowed Progress Effect: How Artificial Advancement Increases Effort, Journal of Consumer Research (March 2006; abstract)
Leenheer, Van Heerde, Bijmolt and Smidts, Do loyalty programs really enhance behavioral loyalty? An empirical analysis accounting for self-selecting members, International Journal of Research in Marketing (March 2007); working version read: Erasmus Research Institute of Management (November 2006)
Liu, The Long-Term Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Purchase Behavior and Loyalty, Journal of Marketing (October 2007; abstract)
Meyer-Waarden and Benavent, Grocery retail loyalty program effects: self-selection or purchase behavior change?, Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science (September 2009; abstract)
Gopalakrishnan, Jiang, Nevskaya and Thomadsen, Can Non-tiered Customer Loyalty Programs Be Profitable?, Marketing Science (online 18 March 2021)
Chen, Evanschitzky and Blut, Understanding Loyalty Program Effectiveness across the Customer Journey: A Meta-Analysis, Journal of Retailing (July 2026; abstract)
Nunes and Drèze, Your Loyalty Program Is Betraying You, Harvard Business Review (2006); summary on CBS News (13 February 2008)
KHN, De horecakeuzes van gasten: dit zijn de tien belangrijkste factoren (10 June 2026)
Toast, 48% of Restaurant Guests Say Being Remembered Matters Most. Only 30% Say It Actually Happens. (2 July 2026)
Tanford, Antecedents and Outcomes of Hospitality Loyalty: A Meta-Analysis, Cornell Hospitality Quarterly (May 2016; abstract)
Dutch Data Protection Authority, Wat zijn persoonsgegevens? (accessed 17 November 2026)
Dutch Data Protection Authority, Grondslagen AVG uitgelegd (accessed 17 November 2026)
Dutch Data Protection Authority, Reclame (accessed 17 November 2026)
Dutch Data Protection Authority, Bewaren van persoonsgegevens (accessed 17 November 2026)
KVK (Ondernemersplein), Privacywetgeving AVG: checklist voor ondernemers (accessed 17 November 2026)
Heo, Dynamic loyalty program for restaurant revenue management, International Journal of Hospitality Management (2026; abstract)
Foodie Coaches, Are Restaurant Loyalty Cards Worth It? (2026) (1 May 2026; inspiration for topic and angle, not a source for figures)
About Guestit
Guestit is one system for reservations, ordering, preparation and payment.
Want to see this work in your business?
Book an introduction and we’ll look together at which of these ideas fit your business. If Guestit isn’t a fit, we’ll say so.

The operating system for hospitality. Connects every step of the guest journey with the processes behind it.
© 2026 Guestit
Privacy · Terms


