Guestit
English
ContactLog inIntroduction

Finance

Part

7

11

min read

The psychology behind a profitable menu

Classify your dishes by popularity and margin, work through an example menu and read what research does and does not say about price anchors and choices.

Cover with the words Menu engineering and a large orange euro symbol

Do this today

Classify the dishes of one type, such as your main courses, into four groups (sold a lot or a little, high or low margin in euros) and choose one dish that you will present differently this week.

Revenue growth says nothing about profit, because costs and volumes can change faster than revenue (our conclusion). CBS (Statistics Netherlands) reported that revenue at eating and drinking establishments in the second quarter of 2026 was 3.5% higher than a year earlier. According to KHN Kompas, the number of tickets fell by 3% in that quarter and 63% of business owners made a profit, against 84% in the first quarter (own research by KHN, the Royal Dutch Hospitality Industry Association; sample not stated). That makes the question of what each dish earns you topical.

After this article you can classify your dishes by popularity and contribution margin (the margin in euros per dish, see part 1), you know what you can do for each group, and you know what research does and does not say about price anchors and choices. This is part 7 of the series "Where does the profit in your restaurant go?" on the Guestit Academy.

How to classify your menu

The method is called menu engineering and is attributed to Michael Kasavana and Donald Smith (1982). We could not consult their book; the thresholds below appear this way in two journal articles that describe the method (LeBruto et al., 1995; Kotschevar, 1987). Do this per type of dish, for example main courses.

  1. Contribution margin per dish: selling price excluding VAT (at 9% VAT: menu price divided by 1.09) minus cost price per portion

  2. Share: portions sold of the dish divided by all portions sold of that type

  3. Popular: a dish with more than 70% of the average share (100% divided by the number of dishes); at exactly 70% the sources differ

  4. High contribution margin: a contribution margin above the weighted average (all contribution margins times the portions sold, added up, divided by all portions sold)

  5. Four groups: popular and high contribution margin is a star (Dutch: winnaar); popular and low contribution margin a plowhorse (hardloper); not popular and high contribution margin a puzzle (slaper); not popular and low contribution margin a dog (verliezer)

KHN uses these names in Dutch and mentions no thresholds on its page; the Excel worksheet is behind a KHN login (not opened). Variants exist (Taylor and Brown, 2007): Miller classifies by cost price instead of contribution margin, Pavesic weights the contribution margin, LeBruto et al. add labour.

Worked example: a made-up menu

Worked example: everything below is made up, not a measurement and not a market price. Eight main courses, sold over four weeks. The menu price includes 9% VAT (the rate for food in hospitality as of 18 November 2026, according to the Belastingdienst, the Dutch Tax and Customs Administration); everything else excludes VAT. We round to whole cents.

  • Burger with fries: menu price €15.50, excluding VAT €14.22, cost price €5.60, contribution margin €8.62; 250 sold (25.0%), total contribution margin €2,155.00

  • Chicken satay with rice: menu price €17.50, excluding VAT €16.06, cost price €5.40, contribution margin €10.66; 200 sold (20.0%), total contribution margin €2,132.00

  • Pesto pasta: menu price €13.50, excluding VAT €12.39, cost price €2.90, contribution margin €9.49; 150 sold (15.0%), total contribution margin €1,423.50

  • Fish and chips: menu price €16.50, excluding VAT €15.14, cost price €7.10, contribution margin €8.04; 120 sold (12.0%), total contribution margin €964.80

  • Salmon with vegetables: menu price €22.50, excluding VAT €20.64, cost price €8.70, contribution margin €11.94; 110 sold (11.0%), total contribution margin €1,313.40

  • Steak: menu price €27.50, excluding VAT €25.23, cost price €10.40, contribution margin €14.83; 80 sold (8.0%), total contribution margin €1,186.40

  • Risotto with mushrooms: menu price €16.00, excluding VAT €14.68, cost price €3.60, contribution margin €11.08; 60 sold (6.0%), total contribution margin €664.80

  • Salad with goat cheese: menu price €14.50, excluding VAT €13.30, cost price €4.90, contribution margin €8.40; 30 sold (3.0%), total contribution margin €252.00

  • Popularity threshold: 100% divided by 8 dishes is 12.5%; times 70% is 8.75%

  • Total contribution margin: €2,155.00 plus €2,132.00 plus €1,423.50 plus €964.80 plus €1,313.40 plus €1,186.40 plus €664.80 plus €252.00 is €10,091.90

  • Weighted average contribution margin: €10,091.90 divided by 1,000 portions sold is €10.09

What to do with each group

  • Stars (chicken satay, salmon): leave them as they are and protect them. KHN advises preferably not to change them without a well-considered reason.

  • Plowhorses (burger, pasta, fish and chips): adjust the price or the cost price. Burger: €1.00 more on the menu is €0.92 more excluding VAT, a contribution margin of €9.54. €2,155.00 divided by €9.54 is 226 portions, rounded up: if more than 24 of the 250 drop out (9.6%), the burger yields less (assuming guests who drop out then order nothing else).

  • Puzzles (steak, risotto): present them differently, for example with a better description or a visible position. Suppose that, thanks to a recommendation, 30 guests per four weeks choose risotto instead of the burger: 30 times (€11.08 minus €8.62) is €73.80 extra, 0.7% of the total contribution margin; the risotto reaches 9.0% and becomes a star. An assumption, not an expectation.

  • Dogs (salad): check the price-quality ratio and raise the price if it is good and competitive; otherwise consider dropping the dish (KHN), unless you have a good reason to keep it.

What the method does not see

The classification is relative: if you change a price or drop a dish, the average and the threshold shift. The contribution margin is calculated with the cost price only; labour is absent from the classic models (Taylor and Brown).

Price anchors and choices: what do we really know?

All of it comes from abroad and need not apply to the Netherlands.

  • Price anchors and decoy options. The anchoring effect (a first number steers your judgement; Tversky and Kahneman, 1974) concerns numbers; the decoy effect (a worse extra option pushes guests towards the option next to it; Huber et al., 1982) has mainly been demonstrated with numbers. In 19 studies with natural stimuli (68 to 681 participants per study), Frederick et al. (2014) found no decoy effect; Yang and Lynn (2014) found 11 reliable effects in 91 attempts and, with descriptions or images, no more than chance; Huber et al. (2014) dispute that. Two online trials with a more expensive decoy dish on a menu found no significant effect (Attwood et al., 2020; hypothetical choices). We saw no measurement anywhere of an expensive dish as an anchor on a real menu.

  • Position. In a small café in Tel Aviv (951 orders, menu order alternated per day) and in a trial with 240 students (hypothetical choices), dishes at the beginning or end of their group were chosen about 20% more often than in the middle; in the café, per category, significant only for soft drinks (Dayan and Bar-Hillel, 2011). In a Swedish canteen with three dishes at one price, the share of meat dishes fell by 11% (from 50% to 44%) when a vegetarian dish was listed at the top (Andersson and Nelander, 2021; 50 days, randomised per day). Kincaid and Corsun (2003) found no significant difference when two pages of one menu were swapped.

  • Number of choices. The best-known experiment (Iyengar and Lepper, 2000: jam in a Californian supermarket, 6 versus 24 varieties) found fewer buyers with 24 varieties: 3% of the visitors who stopped, against 30% with 6 varieties. A meta-analysis of 50 experiments found on average almost no effect, with large differences between studies (Scheibehenne et al., 2010); a later one found that it depends on, among other things, the complexity of the assortment (Chernev et al., 2015). We found no ideal number of dishes.

  • Price presentation. In one restaurant of a culinary school in the US (lunch, 201 tables, menus randomly assigned), tables with prices without currency symbols spent on average $5.55 more (8.15% per person) than with "$" or written-out prices. The overall effect of price presentation was not significant; only a supplementary comparison showed this (Yang, Kimes and Sessarego, 2009; no replication found).

  • Descriptions and photos. In a Stanford canteen (46 days, more than 27,000 guests, analysed per day; a randomly chosen label each day), 25% more guests chose a vegetable with an indulgent description than with the name alone (confidence interval 1 to 49%; Turnwald et al., 2017); this concerned vegetable choice, not contribution margin. We found no measurement of the effect of photos on dishes sold.

  • Recommendations. In five locations of a Beijing restaurant chain, randomly chosen tables received a list of the five most popular dishes of the week before: demand for those dishes rose by 13 to 20%; showing five dishes without their popularity gave no significant effect (Cai, Chen and Fang, 2009).

In summary: position, recommendations and descriptions have been studied with real guests, but according to a meta-analysis of 53 articles (Ip and Chark, 2023) the effect of menu design on actual purchases is marginal but significant, and smaller in field research than in the laboratory. For price anchors on a menu, decoys and the number of dishes, the evidence is weak, disputed or absent. "Can help" is the strongest thing you may say.

Helping guests choose without misleading them

The ACM (the Netherlands Authority for Consumers and Markets) writes in its Leidraad Bescherming Online Consument (guidelines on protecting the online consumer) that tempting is allowed, but influence goes too far when tactics steer the average consumer towards a choice they would not have made had they been able to choose in a well-considered way. The guidelines are about online sales; whether they apply to a menu in your venue, we did not assess, and we are not lawyers. On prices the ACM writes: state the price in euros, including VAT, list extra options separately and do not tick anything in advance; whether a menu without a euro sign meets this, we did not assess.

Safe, in our reading, is: a visible price for every dish, a recommendation that is accurate (only put "popular" next to what is popular according to your POS), no price that only becomes apparent later, and suggestions that the guest adds themselves.

How to test a change

What worked elsewhere may not work for you; so test it yourself:

  1. One change at a time: choose one dish and one adjustment; change no prices and run no promotions in those weeks.

  2. Measure four weeks beforehand: the share of the dish and the contribution margin per guest (the total contribution margin of all dishes divided by the number of guests). Put the average check value from part 4 next to it.

  3. Measure four comparable weeks afterwards, on the same weekdays; take season and busyness into account (KHN).

  4. Compare two numbers: the share and the contribution margin per guest. More attention for one dish can come at the expense of another (KHN).

  5. Decide: leave it in place, reverse it or adjust it. A small difference can be down to chance.

Do this today

Classify the dishes of one type, such as your main courses, into four groups (sold a lot or a little, high or low margin in euros) and choose one dish that you will present differently this week. Take the portions sold over the last four weeks from your POS and the cost prices from your recipe cards. Work out the contribution margin per dish (the menu price divided by 1.09 at 9% VAT, minus the cost price), calculate the popularity threshold (7% for ten dishes) and the weighted average, and classify the dishes. Write down what you change. With cost prices and POS figures at hand this takes thirty minutes at most and needs no purchase; if the cost prices are missing, work out one dish first.

How to calculate a cost price is explained in part 1.

Where technology helps

For menu engineering, a spreadsheet with POS data is enough. On the Guestit eMenu, dishes, photos, prices and availability come from the Guestit CMS and the POS, so a change reaches every tablet without you touching it. That can make it easier to organise a test with one change; that is a consideration, not a demonstrated effect. The eMenu shows large photos and suggestions for a drink or side dish that are easy to ignore and are never added or ticked automatically. Whether that changes the contribution margin per guest, you measure yourself. More about presentation on a tablet: part 6.

How we put this together

The menu and all the numbers are made up; we checked the sums with a calculation script. From KHN we used the Kompas news item, the page on menu engineering and the webinar report, not the Kompas report behind an account; we read CBS, ACM and the Belastingdienst ourselves. Of eleven journal articles and working papers we read the full text, of eight others only the abstract. We did not open the book by Kasavana and Smith or the KHN worksheet. Crossref and OpenAlex show no retraction for articles with a DOI; Turnwald et al. (two swapped p-values) and Chernev et al. (test statistics on one page; not linked by Crossref, not assessed by us) did receive a correction. For the three FIU articles we could not check this. A correction or a better source? Email hey@guestit.nl.

Sources

  1. Statistics Netherlands (CBS), Omzet horeca groeit in tweede kwartaal 2026 met ruim 2 procent (1 September 2026)

  2. Royal Dutch Hospitality Industry Association (KHN), Horeca blijft overeind, maar vraag en rendement staan onder druk (5 August 2026, updated 27 August 2026; news item about KHN's own research, sample not stated; the full Kompas report is behind an account and was not read)

  3. Royal Dutch Hospitality Industry Association (KHN), Menu-engineering-programma (published 19 April 2019, last modified 10 February 2026 according to the page details; the Excel worksheet is behind a KHN login and was not opened)

  4. LeBruto, Quain and Ashley, Menu Engineering: A Model Including Labor, FIU Hospitality Review 13(1) (1995; American authors; full text read)

  5. Kotschevar, Menu Analysis: Review and Evaluation, FIU Hospitality Review 5(2) (1987; comparison on four dishes; full text read)

  6. Taylor and Brown, Menu Analysis: A Review of Techniques and Approaches, FIU Hospitality Review 25(2) (2007; review article; full text read)

  7. Dutch Tax and Customs Administration (Belastingdienst), Btw-tarief voedingsmiddelen (page without a date; accessed 18 November 2026)

  8. Tversky and Kahneman, Judgment under Uncertainty: Heuristics and Biases, Science (1974; participants not in the abstract; only the abstract was read, via PubMed)

  9. Huber, Payne and Puto, Adding Asymmetrically Dominated Alternatives: Violations of Regularity and the Similarity Hypothesis, Journal of Consumer Research (1982; participants and country not in the abstract; only the abstract was read, via OpenAlex)

  10. Frederick, Lee and Baskin, The Limits of Attraction, Journal of Marketing Research (2014; 19 studies with students and visitors to a party on 4 July, 68 to 681 participants per study; no commissioning party named; full text read)

  11. Yang and Lynn, More Evidence Challenging the Robustness and Usefulness of the Attraction Effect, Journal of Marketing Research (2014; 91 attempts in 23 product classes, participants not in the abstract; only the abstract was read)

  12. Huber, Payne and Puto, Let's be Honest about the Attraction Effect, Journal of Marketing Research (2014; commentary by the original authors; only the abstract was read)

  13. Attwood, Chesworth and Parkin, Menu engineering to encourage sustainable food choices when dining out: An online trial of priced-based decoys, Appetite (2020; researchers from the United Kingdom, two online trials, hypothetical choices; number of participants and commissioning party not in the abstract; only the abstract was read, via PubMed)

  14. Dayan and Bar-Hillel, Nudge to nobesity II: Menu positions influence food orders, Judgment and Decision Making (2011; Israel; no commissioning party named, the café cooperated; full text read)

  15. Andersson and Nelander, Nudge the Lunch: A Field Experiment Testing Menu-Primacy Effects on Lunch Choices, Games (2021; Sweden; funded by Riksbankens Jubileumsfond and Handelsbankens forskningsstiftelse; full text read)

  16. Kincaid and Corsun, Are consultants blowing smoke? An empirical test of the impact of menu layout on item sales, International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management (2003; one menu, four months; country, venue and number of guests not in the abstract; only the abstract was read)

  17. Iyengar and Lepper, When choice is demotivating: Can one desire too much of a good thing?, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology (2000; United States; no commissioning party named, the store cooperated; full text read)

  18. Scheibehenne, Greifeneder and Todd, Can There Ever Be Too Many Options? A Meta-Analytic Review of Choice Overload, Journal of Consumer Research (2010; 63 conditions from 50 experiments, 5,036 participants; only the abstract was read)

  19. Chernev, Böckenholt and Goodman, Choice overload: A conceptual review and meta-analysis, Journal of Consumer Psychology (2015; 99 observations, 7,202 participants; only the abstract was read) with the corrigendum concerning test statistics on p. 348, Journal of Consumer Psychology 26(2): 312 (27 July 2015; only the notice was read)

  20. Yang, Kimes and Sessarego, Menu price presentation influences on consumer purchase behavior in restaurants, International Journal of Hospitality Management (2009; United States; 256 surveys, 201 in the analysis; supported by a research initiative of the Culinary Institute of America; author's version read)

  21. Turnwald, Boles and Crum, Association Between Indulgent Descriptions and Vegetable Consumption: Twisted Carrots and Dynamite Beets, JAMA Internal Medicine (2017; United States; funded by the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation and the National Science Foundation; corrected on 24 July 2017; PubMed also links two commentaries, which we did not read; full text read via PubMed Central)

  22. Cai, Chen and Fang, Observational Learning: Evidence from a Randomized Natural Field Experiment, American Economic Review (2009; China; abstract read) and the working paper NBER Working Paper 13516 (2007; full text read; research supported by the Institute for Social and Policy Studies at Yale)

  23. Ip and Chark, The effect of menu design on consumer behavior: A meta-analysis, International Journal of Hospitality Management 108 (2023; 53 articles, 16,522 participants, 44 of the 53 studies from the United States, 12 field studies; supported by the University of Macau and the government of Macau; full text read via a copy in a university library)

  24. Netherlands Authority for Consumers and Markets (ACM), Prijzen vermelden (last modified 7 July 2026 according to the page details; accessed 18 November 2026)

  25. Netherlands Authority for Consumers and Markets (ACM), Leidraad Bescherming Online Consument (May 2024; concerns online sales, not assessed for a menu in a hospitality venue)

  26. Royal Dutch Hospitality Industry Association (KHN), Slim sturen met je menukaart: concrete tips voor meer marge (3 November 2026, updated 4 November 2026; report of a webinar with the founder of Smart Menu Design)

  27. Crossref, Metadata and abstracts of the journal articles and the check for corrections, supplemented with OpenAlex and PubMed and a title search for corrections (retrieved 18 November 2026)

About Guestit

Guestit is one system for reservations, ordering, preparation and payment.

Want to see this work in your business?

Book an introduction and we’ll look together at which of these ideas fit your business. If Guestit isn’t a fit, we’ll say so.

Book an introduction
See the solutions
Guestit

The operating system for hospitality. Connects every step of the guest journey with the processes behind it.

© 2026 Guestit

Privacy · Terms