Operations
10
min read
Upselling in hospitality without being pushy
What research says about upselling by floor staff and screens, which rules matter and how to measure for yourself with POS data if a suggestion works.

How do you suggest something extra to a guest without it feeling pushy? The topic is timely: according to payment data from ING (a Dutch bank), the volume sold at restaurants and cafés fell by 1.6% in the first half of 2026 compared with a year earlier, while revenue rose by almost 3%, entirely due to higher prices according to ING. That makes spend per guest a logical focus (our conclusion, not ING's). Below: what research says about suggestions from floor staff and screens, what guests find annoying, which rules come into play and how to measure for yourself whether a suggestion works. Much of the research is from abroad or small; we say so each time. Data as of 17 November 2026.
At a glance
A specific question from a staff member can work without pressure
More revenue now can mean fewer visits later
A screen sometimes sells more, sometimes less than a person
With every suggestion, pay attention to price, allergens and free choice
Measure it yourself: like-for-like days, one change at a time
1. A suggestion does not have to feel like pressure
Researchers at Wageningen University (a Dutch university) had cashiers in a self-service restaurant suggest a side dish at breakfast: orange juice, fruit salad or pancakes. In the periods with the juice question, juice accompanied 35 to 42% of the breakfasts sold, against 20% in the baseline period; fruit salad rose from 3% to 9% and pancakes from 1% to 3%. In a survey of 393 visitors, guests did not feel pressured (Van Kleef, Van den Broek and Van Trijp, 2015; only the abstract was read). It concerned one venue and a study of healthier choices: it shows that a question at the checkout can shift what guests add, not what it yields in your venue.
KHN (Royal Horeca Netherlands, the hospitality trade association) calls upselling and cross-selling a way to give guests good service. KHN names no source; read it as a position (KHN).
What it means for your venue. A targeted question about a particular side dish did not create a feeling of pressure in this study; the exact words are not in the abstract. Whether a fixed script helps with that is a separate question: in an American study of 2,407 hospitality customers (Cornell, 2012; only the abstract was read), almost half had a predominantly negative view of scripted service, while about a third found scripts useful for carrying out tasks correctly. That was about service in general; the abstract does not mention selling.
What you can do now. For each part of the day, choose one product that your team stands behind and let them offer it in their own words, with the extra charge mentioned. Ask once; a no is a no.
2. Revenue now can cost visits later
A field study of 2,381 guests of a large national casual-dining chain, with a follow-up measurement among 352 guests a month later, found that upselling increased revenue in the short term but had an adverse effect on guests' attitude and thereby on future visits. The counterpart, downselling (the abstract does not describe what exactly that is), cost no revenue in the short term and led to a better attitude and more visits (Norvell, Kumar and Contractor, 2018; one chain, country not named, only the abstract was read; whether visits were measured or self-reported is not stated).
We did not find a Dutch measurement of pushy selling. The closest we found was POS supplier Lightspeed, with two studies in 2025 among 1,371 and 1,100 restaurant visitors in the Netherlands (press release of 11 February 2026; question wording not stated): the announcement that you can order via the QR code on the table annoyed 18%. That is not about upselling, but what floor staff say can also be annoying.
What it means for your venue. Revenue per ticket is not the only number. What you can do now. Alongside revenue, also record complaints and reviews that are about a suggestion and, if you can, how often known guests return.
3. A screen sometimes sells more, sometimes less than a person
Self-order kiosk supplier Ordering Stack (December 2025) writes that a kiosk with well-configured upsell tips can produce tickets up to 15% higher than ordering from a cashier, without naming a source, sample or period (Ordering Stack). That is marketing from a supplier; we cannot verify whether a measurement lies behind it. Scientific research is mixed; of each study below we read only the abstract.
In a field experiment in a quick-service venue (Leung, Torres and Fan, 2021; country not named), guests rated ordering via a kiosk better, but ordering from a cashier produced more revenue; in busy periods the cashier also produced more sales.
At a restaurant chain that introduced a device on the table to support service at the table (Tan and Netessine, 2020; country not named; the staffing level did not change), spend per ticket rose by an estimated 1% or so and meal duration fell by almost 10%; together roughly 11% more sales per minute.
A series of studies, including six field studies (Abell, Biswas and Arroyo Mera, 2024; country not named), found that digital ordering (kiosks, tablets and apps) more often led to less healthy orders and a higher total spend than non-digital ordering; that effect was smaller among guests who accept technology easily.
What it means for your venue. A screen is a channel, not a guarantee: whether a suggestion brings in more can depend on your guests and on how busy you are. We found no independent Dutch measurement of the effect of QR ordering, tablet menus or self-order kiosks on spend; the Netherlands does not appear in any of these three abstracts. The menu steers too, according to a KHN report on menu design (webinar of 2 November 2026): position, description, recommendation and price presentation can influence the choice.
What you can do now. Ask a supplier who promises a higher ticket about the method, period and comparison group, and measure it for yourself (point 5).
On Guestit's self-order kiosk you set, per product, which suggestion the guest sees at the moment they choose, for example a sauce with fries or a drink with a dish.
4. With every suggestion, pay attention to price, allergens and a free choice
Price. According to the ACM (the Netherlands Authority for Consumers and Markets), you state the selling price for consumers in euros, including VAT, and you state extra options separately from that price. For a suggestion with an extra charge, that price should therefore be shown separately alongside it (our reading of the rule).
Default options. Article 6:230j of the Dutch Civil Code (Burgerlijk Wetboek) says that without express consent a consumer is not bound to an additional payment for something that is not the core of the performance, and that default options that the consumer has to reject do not count as express consent. The ACM writes in its guidance on online consumer protection (May 2024) that, with an order, you do not tick by default extra options or products that the consumer has not actively chosen themselves, and on its page on prices that the consumer then does not have to pay the costs. We are not lawyers. Article 6:230j is in a section that does not apply to contracts via vending machines or automated commercial premises (article 6:230h, paragraph 2, point (l)); we did not assess whether an ordering screen in a hospitality venue falls under it.
Allergens. According to the NVWA (the Netherlands Food and Consumer Product Safety Authority), for unpackaged products, such as in hospitality, you must give the consumer the allergen information in a way other than on a label, for example on the menu. Providing it orally is allowed, but then it must be stated somewhere that guests can ask for it. The NVWA calls it important that the guest has the information before the purchase. If you choose to inform guests orally, then according to KHN the information must also be available in writing or electronically to the staff and the NVWA. In our reading, all of this also applies to the sauce, topping or dessert that you suggest. What the NVWA found in its summer inspections in 2026 you can read in section 8 of our Top 10 hospitality trends for 2027.
Also worth watching. On 11 November 2026 the European Commission presented a proposal for a Digital Fairness Act, aimed at problems consumers experience online, such as misleading design choices (dark patterns) and practices that encourage overspending. It is a proposal, not a law; we have not checked what it means for ordering screens.
What you can do now. Go through your menu and ordering screen: is the price shown with every suggestion, is nothing pre-selected and does your team know the allergens of every extra?
5. How to measure whether a suggestion works
With your POS data you can check for yourself whether a suggestion does anything. Without a set-up, you mostly measure chance.
Choose one suggestion and one main number. For example the share of orders with the suggested extra: the orders with the extra divided by all orders in the same period and the same part of the day. Also look at spend per guest and your margin in euros per plate: according to KHN, extra attention for one dish can come at the expense of another.
Measure first without the suggestion. Record how often the extra is already ordered now. The Wageningen study also began with a baseline period and worked with POS data.
Compare like-for-like days. Monday with Monday, lunch with lunch. KHN advises taking season and busyness into account. According to KHN (May 2026), special days such as Valentine's Day and Good Friday bring in more than twice as much revenue as an average day (period and data source not stated).
Use a comparison group. The British Behavioural Insights Team (2012, on government policy) names random assignment to an intervention group and a control group as the key step that makes a trial stronger than other forms of evaluation. In one venue you can draw lots for which days you make the suggestion; with several locations you can introduce it in phases, as in the study by Tan and Netessine.
Do not change anything else at the same time. No new prices, menu or promotion in the same weeks; note the weather, events and occupancy.
Give it enough orders. Example calculation with made-up numbers, not a measurement: suppose that in reality 20% of your orders contain the extra. With 100 orders, the measured share can by chance alone land between about 12% and 28%, and with 400 between about 16% and 24% (95% interval, normal approximation). To see a rise from 20% to 25% between two periods, according to the standard formula (assuming independent orders; 5% significance, 80% power) you need about 1,100 orders per period. Anyone with few orders therefore has to measure for longer.
Also measure what can go wrong. Count complaints, removed extras and reviews: that can give an initial signal of whether more revenue now comes at the expense of visits later.
Start small
Start with one product and one metric, with price and allergens in order, and measure for a number of full weeks against like-for-like days.
How we put this together
This article was inspired by How to Upsell in a Restaurant Without Being Pushy by Foodie Coaches (1 April 2026), an Australian coaching company. We have not adopted their figures and examples: they name no source and partly concern Australia. We compared two of their ideas with our own sources: that a suggestion can work as hospitality rather than as selling (the Wageningen study, in which guests did not feel pressured, fits with that) and that a suggestion is better off sounding sincere and in one's own words than like a rattled-off script (the Cornell study fits with that, although it was about service in general). Their advice to test small first we developed into the measurement set-up above. Ideas for which we found no source, such as rewarding attempts, we leave out.
Of the scientific publications we read only the abstract; in Crossref, none of the journal articles has a correction or retraction listed. The relevant passages from the rules (Dutch Civil Code, ACM, NVWA) and the market sources (ING, KHN) we read ourselves; figures from suppliers, such as Ordering Stack and Lightspeed, are labelled as such. Where we found no Dutch measurement, the text says so. We are not lawyers and did not assess the rules for ordering screens. Do you have a correction or a better source? Email hey@guestit.nl.
Sources
ING Think, Dutch hospitality 2026: Consumer caution keeps volume growth flat (22 September 2026)
Van Kleef, Van den Broek and Van Trijp, Exploiting the Spur of the Moment to Enhance Healthy Consumption: Verbal Prompting to Increase Fruit Choices in a Self-Service Restaurant, Applied Psychology: Health and Well-Being (2015; only the abstract was read, via PubMed)
KHN, Zo beïnvloed je de keuze van je gast (24 October 2025, updated 23 December 2025; names no sources)
Victorino, Bolinger and Verma, Service Scripting and Authenticity: Insights for the Hospitality Industry, Cornell Center for Hospitality Research (1 October 2012; only the abstract was read)
Norvell, Kumar and Contractor, Assessing the Customer-Based Impact of Up-Selling Versus Down-Selling, Cornell Hospitality Quarterly (2018; only the abstract was read)
Lightspeed, Tafelmanieren dealbreaker: kwart Nederlanders beoordeelt date op eetgedrag (11 February 2026; research by a POS supplier)
Ordering Stack, Proven Upselling Techniques to Boost Your Restaurant Revenue (19 December 2025; marketing by a supplier, without a source for the figure)
Leung, Torres and Fan, Do kiosks outperform cashiers? An S-O-R framework of restaurant ordering experiences, Journal of Hospitality and Tourism Technology (2021; only the abstract was read)
Tan and Netessine, At Your Service on the Table: Impact of Tabletop Technology on Restaurant Performance, Management Science (2020; only the abstract was read)
Abell, Biswas and Arroyo Mera, Food and technology: Using digital devices for restaurant orders leads to indulgent outcomes, Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science (2024; only the abstract was read)
KHN, Slim sturen met je menukaart: concrete tips voor meer marge (3 November 2026; report of a webinar with the founder of Smart Menu Design)
ACM, Prijzen vermelden (last modified 7 July 2026 according to the page information; accessed on 17 November 2026)
Rijksoverheid (the Dutch central government), Burgerlijk Wetboek Boek 6, artikel 230j (wetten.overheid.nl, accessed on 17 November 2026; our reading, not legal advice, not assessed for ordering screens)
ACM, Leidraad Bescherming Online Consument (May 2024; concerns online environments, not assessed for ordering screens in a hospitality venue)
NVWA, Allergenen (last modified 22 January 2026 according to the page information; accessed on 17 November 2026)
KHN, Wat betekent de allergenenwetgeving voor mij? (updated 6 November 2026)
European Commission, Digital Fairness Act (proposal of 11 November 2026)
KHN, KHN Kompas Kwartaalrapportage Q1 2026: omzet onder druk, maar kansen in zicht (12 May 2026)
Behavioural Insights Team (Cabinet Office, United Kingdom), Test, Learn, Adapt: Developing Public Policy with Randomised Controlled Trials (June 2012)
PubMed, Record and abstract of Van Kleef, Van den Broek and Van Trijp (2015) (retrieved on 17 November 2026)
Crossref, Metadata and abstracts of the other journal articles and the check for corrections (retrieved on 17 November 2026; the abstract of Abell et al. came from the Springer page)
Foodie Coaches, How to Upsell in a Restaurant Without Being Pushy (1 April 2026; inspiration for the topic, not a source for figures)
About Guestit
Guestit is one system for reservations, ordering, preparation and payment.
Want to see this work in your business?
Book an introduction and we’ll look together at which of these ideas fit your business. If Guestit isn’t a fit, we’ll say so.

The operating system for hospitality. Connects every step of the guest journey with the processes behind it.
© 2026 Guestit
Privacy · Terms


