Guestit
English
ContactLog inIntroduction

Operations

11

min read

More regular guests in your restaurant? Jon Taffer's strategy

How do you get restaurant guests to come back? Discover Jon Taffer's three-visit strategy and learn how to win more regular guests with personal attention.

Cover with the words Red Napkin and a large orange number 3

Do this today

Work out how many extra visits per 100 new guests a small gesture, such as a free starter, has to generate to earn back its costs.

A guest who enjoyed the meal and was served well does not come back automatically for that reason alone. KHN (Royal Dutch Hospitality Industry Association) writes that in the second quarter of 2026 guests came less often and ordered less; the number of tickets fell by 3% (KHN Kompas, KHN's own research, sample not stated). The American hospitality entrepreneur and TV presenter Jon Taffer says that restaurants focus their marketing on one visit, and that he focuses his on three visits. His tools: a red napkin for new guests, a manager who stops by and a handwritten card for next time. Taffer is not a scientist; his percentages are his own statements; we found no published data behind them. After this article, you will know what Taffer says, what is known apart from him, how many extra visits such a programme has to generate and how to count them without software.

Who is Jon Taffer, and where do his numbers come from?

According to his own site, Taffer presents the television show Bar Rescue, runs the consulting firm Taffer Dynamics and founded the restaurant concept Taffer's Tavern. As the basis for his percentages, in 2026 he names research by his earlier company Guest Probe at about 90,000 restaurants, and in an interview on his site he says that he followed more than 60,000 restaurants for more than thirty years. We could not find Guest Probe, nor any published data. The percentages are therefore statements from the source himself, and they differ from one occasion to the next (chance of a second, third and fourth visit; in 2017 and 2026 the first two refer to flawless visits, according to Taffer):

The higher chance of a fourth visit may also be because people who came three times are already a more loyal group (our reading).

His method: three visits and a red napkin

Taffer described the method in 2017 and 2026 in broadly the same way; his TikTok account calls it the Red Napkin Marketing Tactic (July 2021). The sequence:

  1. Visit 1: the guest comes with a card or coupon for a free rib dinner, without conditions. The restaurant asks whether they have been here before. If not, they get a red napkin and everyone else a white one, so that the team can see who is new. The manager introduces themselves. At the end, the manager writes by hand on the back of a business card: five dollars off the chicken.

  2. Visit 2: the guest puts the card on the table, so that everyone knows it is their second visit. At the end, the manager writes a free piece of cheesecake on it.

  3. Visit 3: the guest comes for the cheesecake. After that, the chance of a fourth visit is 72% according to Taffer (2026).

On the costs, he says in 2026: $4 for the rib dinner, $1 for the postcard, a free piece of cheesecake and a chicken discount that breaks even; together about $8 per new guest, compared with more than $1,000 that others spend on media, according to him (in 2017: about $6 against $40 to $80). He warns against discounts because people get used to them, and prefers something free (2017); his own card does give five dollars off, once. Gary Vaynerchuk, his conversation partner in 2017, observed that regular guests may wonder why they are not treated that way. This is Taffer's description; we found no measurement of what the method delivers.

What do we know apart from Taffer?

We found no fixed standard for the share of new guests who come back; many sources are American.

  • Return of new guests: Bloom Intelligence, a provider of marketing software, reports on 5 June 2026 that more than 8 in 10 new guests do not come back (own network, almost a million guests, 2024 to early 2026; country not named; internal method): read that as marketing. Of the 273 restaurateurs surveyed, about half had offered a Groupon-type discount voucher (daily deal); they reported that 35% of new guests came back without a new offer (Wu, Kimes and Dholakia, Cornell, 2012).

  • Satisfaction and behaviour: a meta-analysis of 102 studies from the hospitality industry found that satisfaction is strongly related to loyalty, but that the effect gets smaller from attitude via intention to behaviour (Tanford, 2016).

  • Offers: of the guests who used a discount voucher (daily deal) in a survey of 931 American consumers, 44% said they were already regular guests; the researchers found the concern about disloyal guests unsubstantiated (Kimes and Dholakia, Cornell, 2011). A KHN adviser wrote in a column from 2014, without sources, that guests who come through discount sites barely return.

  • Personal bond: in a study of 562 guests of Dutch cafés who had come there at least twice in the past year, scores on a scale for the quality of the bond with the staff were associated with loyalty and word of mouth (Velthuis et al., 2026); an association, not proof that attention makes guests come back.

Cornell and Velthuis are based on surveys and Tanford mainly on intentions, not on counts of visits. An offer for new guests can partly go to guests who would have come anyway; that is why it should come with a way to recognise new guests. More about loyalty cards, customer value and privacy: Do loyalty cards in hospitality really pay off?

Worked example: what does a three-visit programme cost?

Worked example: everything below is made up (no measurement, no market price) and per guest; amounts exclude VAT and are rounded to whole cents, and we continue calculating with the amount shown. A fictional restaurant gives a new guest a free starter at visit 1, €5.00 off the menu price at visit 2 (including 9% VAT, the rate for food in hospitality according to the Belastingdienst (the Dutch Tax and Customs Administration)) and a free dessert at visit 3. We assume that the guest would have come to visit 1 anyway. How to work out a cost price is explained in What does a dish really cost?

  1. Contribution per visit: spending €30.00 minus cost price of what the guest orders €10.50 is €19.50

  2. Costs at visit 1: starter €2.40 plus card €0.10 plus manager (2 minutes at €0.50) €1.00 is €3.50

  3. Costs at visit 2: €5.00 divided by 1.09 is €4.59 discount excluding VAT; plus €1.00 manager is €5.59

  4. Costs at visit 3: dessert €1.60 plus €1.00 manager is €2.60

  5. On paper, per guest who uses everything: starter, discount, dessert and card: €2.40 plus €4.59 plus €1.60 plus €0.10 is €8.69 in what you give away

  6. Per 100 new guests (made up: 30 come for visit 2, 12 of them for visit 3): 100 times €3.50 is €350.00, 30 times €5.59 is €167.70 and 12 times €2.60 is €31.20; together €548.90

  7. Per guest who came three times: all €548.90 divided by 12 is €45.74

  8. Earning it back: €548.90 divided by €19.50 is 28.15, so at least 29 extra visits (28 times €19.50 is €546.00)

Only extra visits count: on guests who would have come without the programme anyway, you earn nothing back. Here, 42 visits come back (30 plus 12). Had 20 come without the programme, there would be 22 extra: 22 times €19.50 is €429.00, a loss of €119.90. Had it been 10, there would be 32 extra: €624.00, a profit of €75.10. In our reading, Taffer's figure of about $8 counts only what he gives away (as in line 5), not the guests who drop out (line 7).

How to measure it without expensive software

  1. Card (one per guest): at each visit, write on it the date (that way you also see the time between visits), the number of this visit and until when it is valid. Do not put a name, phone number or card number on it.

  2. Tally sheet: the host asks each table who has been here before and makes a tally mark per guest at “first time”, at the number on the card or at “been before, without a card”.

  3. Three percentages: second visit: cards with number 1 that are brought back, divided by the number of new guests; third visit: cards with number 2 divided by cards with number 1; fourth visit: cards with number 3 divided by cards with number 2. A card that stays at home does not count: read it as a lower bound.

  4. Extra visits and contribution: for four weeks before the start, count how many guests say “been before”, and do the same again in four comparable weeks as soon as the first cards can come back (same weekdays; watch for season, weather and events). The difference is a rough estimate of extra visits; multiply it by the contribution per visit and subtract the costs. A small difference can be chance.

Our suggestion: start small, with one service or weekday, for four weeks. In our reading, a card with only a date and a number records nothing about a person. According to the Autoriteit Persoonsgegevens (AP, the Dutch Data Protection Authority), a name, phone number or customer number does count as personal data; you may only process it if you cannot reach your purpose in another way, you need a legal basis for it, and for advertising consent is needed in many cases.

Where it goes wrong

  • Calculating too optimistically: time and drop-outs are part of the costs (compare line 5 with 6 and 7) and only extra visits earn them back.

  • Giving attention only to new guests: address regular guests personally too.

  • A process that disappears in the rush: choose one signal that your team sees, such as a napkin in a different colour, and one moment for the manager.

  • Taking American numbers as the norm: one entrepreneur and one presenter are not a measurement; base your target on your own figures.

Do this today

Work out how many extra visits per 100 new guests a small gesture, such as a free starter, has to generate to earn back its costs. Take the average spend per guest excluding VAT from your POS and the cost price of what a guest orders from your recipe cards; the difference is the contribution per visit. Add the card and your manager's time per guest (in the example 2 minutes) to the cost price of the gesture and divide that by the contribution. In the worked example, for the starter that is €3.50 divided by €19.50: 0.18 extra visits per new guest, so 18 per 100. With the cost prices at hand, this takes thirty minutes at most, with no purchase and without Guestit; if they are missing, first work out one dish.

You can read how to work out a cost price and why a ticket is not a guest in What does a dish really cost? and Five figures every hospitality owner must know.

Where technology helps

You do not need software for this programme: a tally sheet and a spreadsheet are enough. In the Guestit POS you view reports per period, compared with the previous period or a year earlier; that can help to put your test weeks next to the weeks before. Guestit Insights is meant to show figures from the POS.

How we put this together

Data as of 18 November 2026. We read Taffer's statements in the automatically generated English subtitles of the February 2026 YouTube episode (we neither saw nor heard the video itself; subtitles can contain errors; 47%, 90,000 restaurants, Guest Probe and $1 for the postcard appear only there; 42%, 72%, $4, $8 and $1,000 also in a hotel trade publication that quotes from the interview), in the transcript on Gary Vaynerchuk's blog (2017) and in the interview on Taffer's own site. We did not open his book Raise the Bar; of the TikTok video we read only the description. Of the Cornell reports and Tanford we read only the abstract; of Velthuis the full text (open access). For the journal articles, Crossref shows no correction or retraction, a title search on Correction, Corrigendum and Erratum found none, and PubMed does not contain them. We read KHN, the AP, the Belastingdienst and Nation's Restaurant News ourselves. We checked the sums with a script. Could not be verified, so left out or given with a reservation: the data behind Taffer's percentages, a fixed standard for the share of new guests who return and Dutch research on what a red napkin or card delivers. Do you have a correction or a better source? Email hey@guestit.nl.

Sources

  1. You Gotta Try This (YouTube), Jon Taffer Explains The Economics Of Running A Restaurant | You Gotta Try This Ep. 53 (23 February 2026; interview with Taffer, passage from about 32:30 to 35:00; only the automatically generated English subtitles read; the description ends with “Food Deserves Pepsi”; Pepsi's role is not stated there)

  2. 10 Minutes News for Hoteliers, Jon Taffer's Playbook for Restaurant Turnarounds (26 February 2026; hotel trade publication that quotes from the same interview)

  3. Gary Vaynerchuk, The Three Best Restaurant Tips for Customer Retention (17 July 2017; transcript of an episode of AskGaryVee with Taffer)

  4. Jon Taffer, Burger-Bar Rescue Advice from Jon Taffer (interview, originally on BurgerBusiness.com; date not stated)

  5. Jon Taffer, About (jontaffer.com; accessed 18 November 2026; self-description)

  6. Jon Taffer (TikTok), Red Napkin Marketing Tactic (28 July 2021; only the description read)

  7. Bloom Intelligence, 8 in 10 First-Time Restaurant Guests Never Come Back (5 June 2026; blog of a marketing software supplier; own network, internal method, not independently checked)

  8. Kimes and Dholakia, Restaurant Daily Deals: Customers' Responses to Social Couponing, Cornell Center for Hospitality Research (2011; survey of 931 American consumers; commissioning party not stated; only the abstract read)

  9. Wu, Kimes and Dholakia, Restaurant Daily Deals: The Operator Experience, Cornell Center for Hospitality Research (2012; survey of 273 restaurateurs, of whom, according to the abstract, about half offered a discount voucher; country and commissioning party not stated; only the abstract read)

  10. Nation's Restaurant News, Research: Operators reveal pros and cons of daily deals (12 December 2012; trade publication; coverage of the Cornell report by Wu, Kimes and Dholakia: online survey at the end of 2011 among subscribers of Nation's Restaurant News and Restaurant Hospitality, which helped with the research; 49.4% of the 273 respondents had offered a discount voucher)

  11. Royal Dutch Hospitality Industry Association (KHN), Creëren we WAARDEloze gasten? (column by a KHN domain adviser, 19 December 2014; names no sources)

  12. Tanford, Antecedents and Outcomes of Hospitality Loyalty, Cornell Hospitality Quarterly (May 2016; meta-analysis of 102 studies; commissioning party not stated; only the abstract read)

  13. Velthuis, Mitas, Cavagnaro and Bastiaansen, Development of a commercial friendship quality scale in Dutch pubs, International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management (22 April 2026; 562 guests of Dutch cafés who had come to the same venue at least twice in the past year; questionnaire, loyalty self-reported; no commissioning party named; full text read, open access)

  14. Royal Dutch Hospitality Industry Association (KHN), Horeca blijft overeind, maar vraag en rendement staan onder druk (5 August 2026; news item about KHN's own research, sample not stated; the full KHN Kompas report is behind a login and was not read)

  15. Dutch Data Protection Authority (AP), Wat zijn persoonsgegevens? (updated 16 September 2026; accessed 18 November 2026)

  16. Dutch Data Protection Authority (AP), Grondslagen AVG uitgelegd (updated 16 September 2026; accessed 18 November 2026)

  17. Dutch Data Protection Authority (AP), Reclame (updated 4 April 2025; accessed 18 November 2026)

  18. Dutch Tax and Customs Administration (Belastingdienst), Btw-tarief voedingsmiddelen (last modified 5 March 2026 according to the page information; accessed 18 November 2026)

  19. Crossref, Metadata and abstracts of the journal articles and the check for corrections, supplemented with OpenAlex (abstracts of the Cornell reports), PubMed and a title search for corrections (retrieved 18 November 2026)

About Guestit

Guestit is one system for reservations, ordering, preparation and payment.

Want to see this work in your business?

Book an introduction and we’ll look together at which of these ideas fit your business. If Guestit isn’t a fit, we’ll say so.

Book an introduction
See the solutions
Guestit

The operating system for hospitality. Connects every step of the guest journey with the processes behind it.

© 2026 Guestit

Privacy · Terms