Guestit
English
ContactLog inIntroduction

Finance

7

min read

Menu engineering: the 24-question checklist

Review your menu with 24 questions in twelve parts, see at once where you are leaving something on the table and pick at most three actions for this week.

Cover with the words Menu check and a large orange number 24

Do this today

Fill in the Menu check on this page with your current menu and the sales figures for the past four weeks next to it, and pick at most three actions for this week with a name and a day for each.

Menu check

24 questions about your menu

Answer the questions honestly. You see straight away where you are leaving something on the table, and you pick at most three actions for this week.

1. Menu layout

0/2

Are your highest-margin dishes in a prominent spot (a box, or at the top or bottom of a section)?

Is the menu divided into clear sections you can read at a glance?

2. Your numbers

0/2

Do you know the margin in euros of every dish?

Do you track the average spend per guest?

3. Prices

0/2

Have you reviewed your prices in the past quarter?

Do you set prices deliberately per dish, instead of cost price plus a fixed mark-up?

4. Descriptions

0/2

Does the description say what makes a dish special (origin, preparation)?

Does every description match what is on the plate?

5. Sides and desserts

0/2

Are sides and desserts visible at the moment the guest chooses?

Do you know how many tables out of ten order a dessert?

6. Extras

0/2

Are extras (a sauce, a drink) listed with the dish they go with?

Is a suggestion for an extra built into the ordering process (POS, ordering screen or a set phrase)?

7. Online menu

0/2

Is your online menu the same as the menu in your venue (prices and items)?

Do you update the online menu for the season and for what has run out?

8. Team

0/2

Does your team know which dishes earn the most?

Does your team have a natural phrase for recommending something?

9. Promotion

0/2

Do you put one dish in the spotlight every week (online or in the venue)?

Do your posts include a link to your menu or to booking?

10. Simplifying

0/2

Do you take dishes off the menu that sell little and earn little?

Do dishes share ingredients, so you throw away less?

11. Cost price

0/2

Do you recalculate recipes and portions when purchase prices change?

Do you weigh or measure portions, so every plate costs the same?

12. Rhythm

0/2

Do you review the menu at least every quarter with the sales figures at hand?

Do you record who changes what and when?

Result
0 out of 24answered yes

24 questions to go.

Where you are leaving something on the table

Answer a few questions first: every question without a yes appears here.

Your input stays in this browser. Nothing is sent. The example figures are made up.

It is easy to change a menu only when you have to: a purchase price goes up, a dish disappears. The rest stays as it was. Menu engineering is the opposite: you review the menu at fixed moments with the figures at hand, and decide per dish what you do with it.

The Menu check at the top of this page helps you do that: 24 questions in twelve parts, from the layout of your menu to the rhythm in which you update it. You see straight away where you are leaving something on the table and you pick at most three actions for this week. Below you can read what menu engineering is, why each part is in there and how to read the result. The check gives no grade and no standard: you decide what matters for your venue.

What is menu engineering?

Menu engineering assesses dishes on two things at once: how often you sell them and what they earn per portion in euros (selling price minus cost price). The method is attributed to Michael Kasavana and Donald Smith. We did not read their book; we follow the description in a journal article by LeBruto, Quain and Ashley (1995). KHN (Royal Dutch Hospitality Industry Association) uses the same classification into four groups: winners, sleepers, fast sellers and losers.

How to work out that classification yourself is explained in The psychology behind a profitable menu.

How to use the tool

  1. Have ready: your menu, your online menu and the sales figures per dish for the past four weeks.

  2. Answer the 24 questions: with "Yes", "No" or "Don't know". For each part you see a counter, for example 1/2.

  3. Look at the result: the number answered yes out of 24, with a bar, and below it the list "Where you are leaving something on the table" with every question that has no yes.

  4. Pick at most three points with the "Pick" button and fill in for each point: "What will you do?", "Who" and "When".

  5. Share the action list: with "Copy" or "Print".

With "Fill in an example" you first see how it works; with "Clear" you start again. What you enter stays in your own browser; nothing is sent.

The twelve parts in brief

  • Menu layout: the spot your highest-margin dishes are in, and sections you can read at a glance.

  • Your numbers: without the margin in euros per dish you cannot make the classification into four groups; the average spend per guest shows whether a change makes a difference. You learn how to calculate a cost price in What does a dish really cost?

  • Prices: purchase prices change, so a price you have not looked at for a long time can have a different margin than you think.

  • Descriptions: a description is meant to help the guest choose, and must match what is on the plate.

  • Sides and desserts: how many tables out of ten order a dessert is something you can count this week.

  • Extras: a fixed place in the ordering process is meant to keep the suggestion from depending on who is working. More in Upselling in hospitality without being pushy.

  • Online menu: if a guest sees a different price online than in your venue, or a dish that has run out, that can raise questions at the table. See The digital menu as a sales tool.

  • Team: your team can only recommend what it knows, in a phrase that suits the person.

  • Promotion: highlighting one dish per week forces you to choose; a link gives the reader a next step.

  • Simplifying: for a dish that sells little and earns little, KHN looks at the price first and then considers stopping, unless you have a good reason to keep it.

  • Cost price: a cost price is only right as long as the purchase price and the portion are right.

  • Rhythm: without a fixed moment and without someone who makes the change, a menu easily gets left as it is. A KHN report of a webinar with a consultancy recommends comparing sales before and after a change and taking season and busyness into account.

Worked example: a completed check

Worked example: the answers below are made up, not a measurement and not a market average. They are the data behind "Fill in an example".

  • Answers: 14 answered yes, 7 answered no and 3 answered don't know; together 24

  • Result: 14 out of 24 answered yes

  • Where you are leaving something on the table: 7 plus 3 is 10 questions

  • Counters: Your numbers and Sides and desserts are at 0/2, six parts at 1/2 and four at 2/2

  • Picked for this week: 3 of those 10; the other 7 remain for a next round

The three actions from the example:

  1. Calculate the margin per dish for the ten best-selling dishes: who: owner; when: Friday

  2. Put desserts on the menu next to the main courses: who: chef; when: next menu change

  3. Check the online menu every Monday: who: manager; when: every week

How to read the result

The result is a count, not a verdict. We found no source that says how many of the 24 points a good menu has, and the check does not say so either. In the same webinar report KHN writes that there is no single perfect menu that works for every hospitality venue. So compare your result with your own previous one.

Then look at the counters: one part at 0/2 is a more logical start than four parts at 1/2.

A meta-analysis of 53 articles, largely American research, found that menu design has a marginal effect on what guests actually buy, and that the effect is smaller in field research than in the laboratory (Ip and Chark, 2023). Whether a change earns you anything, you only see in your own figures.

Common mistakes

  • Answering yes on a hunch: "do you know the margin of every dish" is only a yes if the number is written down somewhere.

  • An action without a name or a day: then nobody is responsible for it.

  • Adding extras automatically: in an offer to consumers you may, according to the ACM (the Netherlands Authority for Consumers and Markets), not tick options in advance or add them to an order by default. The guest chooses a suggestion themselves.

Do this today

Fill in the Menu check on this page with your current menu and the sales figures for the past four weeks next to it, and pick at most three actions for this week with a name and a day for each. If you do not have the sales figures per dish at hand, choose "Don't know" where you are missing the answer. Copy or print the action list and discuss it with your team.

Where technology helps

The check does not need a particular POS: you use the sales figures per dish that your own system gives you. The Guestit POS has reports per period, from a day to a year or a custom period, with a CSV export of exactly the period shown. With the Guestit eMenu, dishes and prices come from the Guestit CMS and the POS, so a change reaches every tablet; with QR ordering you change the menu once and it is on every table. Whether that changes your margin is something you measure yourself.

How we put this together

Our check is based on the Menu Engineering Action Sheet by Foodie Coaches, an Australian coaching company: a checklist with twelve focus areas, two yes/no questions per area and an action list for the week. That structure and part of the topics of the questions have been adopted. The questions have been reworded in Dutch, partly replaced and supplemented; the explanation, the example and the immediate result are ours. The worked example is made up and was recalculated with a script. We read the article by LeBruto et al. in full; on the pages of KHN and the ACM we looked up the passages cited. We did not open the book by Kasavana and Smith or KHN's Excel worksheet (behind a login). Of the meta-analysis by Ip and Chark we read the abstract and the passages cited, via a copy in a university library; not the individual studies. Crossref and OpenAlex show no correction or retraction for it; that does not prove there is none. A correction or a better source? Email hey@guestit.nl.

Sources

  1. KHN, Menu-engineering-programma (published 19 April 2019, last modified 10 February 2026 according to the page data; the Excel worksheet is behind a KHN login and was not opened)

  2. LeBruto, Quain and Ashley, Menu Engineering: A Model Including Labor, FIU Hospitality Review 13(1) (1995; American authors; describes the method of Kasavana and Smith, whose book we did not read; full text read)

  3. KHN, Slim sturen met je menukaart: concrete tips voor meer marge (3 November 2026, updated 4 November 2026; report of a KHN webinar with a consultancy for menus)

  4. Ip and Chark, The effect of menu design on consumer behavior: A meta-analysis, International Journal of Hospitality Management 108 (2023; 53 articles, 16,522 participants, 44 of the 53 studies from the United States, 12 field studies; supported by the University of Macau and the government of Macau; abstract and cited passages read via a copy in a university library)

  5. ACM, Prijzen vermelden (last modified 7 July 2026 according to the page data; accessed 19 November 2026)

  6. Foodie Coaches, Menu Engineering Action Sheet (worksheet, PDF; example for the structure of the check, not a source of figures)

About Guestit

Guestit is one system for reservations, ordering, preparation and payment.

Want to see this work in your business?

Book an introduction and we’ll look together at which of these ideas fit your business. If Guestit isn’t a fit, we’ll say so.

Book an introduction
See the solutions
Guestit

The operating system for hospitality. Connects every step of the guest journey with the processes behind it.

© 2026 Guestit

Privacy · Terms